When people are diminished, they grow sullen and their anger builds. While those who created the system never favored popular vote, they certainly didnt expect anyone to win the majority of the electoral vote, either. One person, one vote is the democratic manifestation of the constitutions promise that all men are created equal. While we are definitionally a republic, we were initially constituted as a republic of slave owners who preached democratic ideals far more than they practiced them. The electoral college has been part of the US's history and tradition and to abolish it would require a constitutional amendment. Learn more about how the Gallup Poll Social Series works. AP Gov Electoral College Flashcards Flashcards | Quizlet And her grandmother before her. CP: Supporters of the electoral college system suggest that this isn't necessarily a problem from a democratic standpoint as in many states electors are voted in in primaries and so the electoral college system is as democratic as other another system e.g. What resulted was a desire to create uniformity and stability. Yale Law Professor Akhil Reed Amar has been a vocal advocate for using the popular vote for presidential elections. The Electoral College - Pros and Cons - Dave Leip's Atlas of U.S Top 10 Reasons It's Time to Abolish the Electoral College - ListLand The Electoral College, although it has been used for quite some time now, may not necessarily be that system. Its time that we begin to truly amend this broken process and finally restore democracy. And now he's stubbornly holding on to the dream that his court challenges of elections in key swing states will flip reality on its head and give him another term at the expense of Joe Biden and the Democrats. In the United States, the Electoral College is a winner-take-all system that adequately supports two parties, making it difficult for third party candidates to secure a win. The constitution contains minimal provisions when it comes to deciding who each states electors are going to be. At least the Post had the decency to admit their scenario wouldn't likely happen, and that if it did, there may be "unintended consequences." When they got commissioned the first cushion cover, both Ayda and her mother took on this project and it took 3 months to complete the job, creating the first Sasik-style cover. In 2008, Plutzer suggested that while the popular vote would be beneficial, the country had a patchwork of voting technologies that would prevent its implementation. Majority supports changing Electoral College system for U.S Reasons to Keep the Electoral College - ThoughtCo The 2023 Season Outlook for Dallas Cowboys, Pros and Cons for Each Team to Win the Super Bowl LVII, Top 10 Reasons School Uniforms Should Be Banned, Top 10 Reasons Jesus Christ Never Existed, 10 Reasons The Death Penalty Should Be Legal, Top 10 Reasons Euthanasia Should Be Legal Everywhere, Affiliate, Paid, and Sponsored Post Disclosure, Thank you for your Sponsored Post Purchase. Those "flyover states" would be diminished. The second time a tie happened was during the Presidential election of 1824. Americans' evaluations of the economy are marginally better than in August, but their satisfaction with the state of the nation is unchanged and stuck near historical lows. The Electoral College has come under fire for lacking fairness and ignoring the will of voters across the nation. Of the seven times this question was asked over the past two decades, support for amending the Constitution to abolish the Electoral College only fell below the majority level once -- in November 2016 after Donald Trump won the electoral vote and Hillary Clinton the popular vote. Because the procedure for electing the president is part of the Constitution, a Constitutional Amendment (which requires two-thirds approval in both houses of Congress plus approval by 38 states) would be required to abolish the Electoral College. You don't want somebody you don't know in another state to have a gun? List Land Recommends Monumetric. Today, technology allows for an informed national electorate as, Electoral College Amar suggested same-day voter registration, early voting, and a national election holiday as methods for increasing turnout that would also be positive outcomes of a popular vote. Stanford University Professor Jack Rakove suggested in 2016 that the Electoral College weighs votes differently based on state. From management to chiefs, to security guards, to the safari guides and drivers, the entire lodge is run by and managed by amazing Tanzanian women. The Electoral College was created for two reasons. Other counties tend to have many political parties, where each district is assigned many seats, not just one. 2. But first he needs to save the Senate majority. The Electoral College was created because "normal citizens" were not deemed worth of voting because they would not know what or who they were voting for. The amendments Fully overhauling the way the president is selected would take a Constitutional amendment, which would require the votes of two-thirds of. The reasons for rejection were the poor state of communications and the large distances in between the states. Traditionally, presidential candidates will spend more time, energy, and money working with swing states as compared to others. Partisans' preferences for the way to elect a president in the U.S. since 2000. A 2016 article in Time Magazine argued that neither system would encourage candidates to spend a lot of time in small states or rural areas. Definition of the Problem: You might remember that someone mentioned "unintended consequences.". Learn how to discover the data you need to help your organization make better decisions and create meaningful change. Explain two reasons why the electoral college has not been abolished. Opponents of the Electoral College also feel that the distribution of Electoral Votes is uneven and unfair between states. Like so many institutions rotting our crumbling empire to its core, the electoral college was built entirely around the demands of slave owners. This film features Dunia Camp, the only all-female safari lodge in Africa. By continuing, you are agreeing to receive cookies. They are the embodiment of strength a beaming light of ambition and resilience in a world built by and for men they have taken their rightful place leading with grace and power. 10 Reasons Why We Should Abolish the Electoral College As Althouse (2011) concludes, Direct popular election of the President is the only real reform (p. 994). This was seen in the 2000 election, where a President was elected without winning the popular vote. I was born and raised in South Africa, and have always considered myself an African woman, however, I was also very privileged to grow up in a culture that never said I could not be or do anything I wanted. The study is absolutely stunningstating that Republicans are expected to win 65% of presidential races in which they narrowly lose the popular vote, thanks to the concentration of Democrats in solid blue states. Any rudimentary study of the time when our Constitution was being written reveals that slavery was at the heart of every dispute in this new government as far as appropriating political power goes, and youll never guess what Madison said the solution was to fusing a practical union between this difficulty in presidential elections. You could punch a kid, or he could punch you, and half an hour later you could both ride your bikes to a convenience store for a Slurpee. We draw a different lesson: It is alarming that a candidate came so close to winning while polling more than 5 million fewer votes than his opponent nationwide. The electoral college compounds this arbitrary distribution of very real power. It discriminates against third parties. Click card to see definition Today, with universal education, TV, radio, newspapers, and the Internet, voters can learn about candidates for themselves. To all the girls I say "Let's stay crazy" and with it, a brighter, and more beautiful future lies ahead. Abolish the electoral college. She has promoted policies aimed at achieving social, economic, and political justice for all Tanzanians, however, I belive her greatest accomplishment since becoming president is how she has shown and inspired all the women young and old of East Africa to continue to belive in themselves, that anything is possible, no matter what the world says. Pearson, C. (2020, March-April). 3 Myths About Abolishing the Electoral College. That is the genesis of things like the Three-Fifths compromise. Hyper-blue New York City (save for Manhattan) drags the rest of the extremely populous state to the left, and ensures that upstate New York Republicans have just as much say in U.S. presidential elections as they do in the Canadian elections across the border. Smaller states, as a result, have greater Electoral power per person. If you extend this ruling to a national scale in the presidential election, you can see how it got conservatives all hot and bothered when MSNBCs Chris Hayes asserted that the Electoral College is unconstitutional (according to the Warren Court, hes almost surely correct). If Democratic nominee John F. Kerry hadnt lost Ohio by just 120,000 votes in 2004, he would have won an electoral college victory despite trailing President George W. Bush by 3million votes in the national count. In May 2019, Gallup released polling data that show 55% of respondents favoring a constitutional amendment to adopt the popular vote for presidential elections. Hundreds of years have passed since the framers established the Electoral College. 2023. But the idea of using the skills of the women of the family to create cushion covers with patterns inspired by the famous Zanzibar doors came from the owner of the first hotel in Stone Town, the Emerson. It favors small states because each elector actually represents fewer people than the electors in larger states. This is just as important as having a president who is equally representative of the interests of each state. This is likely the main reason behind Democrats' strong support -- and Republicans' strong opposition -- to changing the current system to use the popular vote to elect the U.S. president. The camp is located in the heart of Tanzania's Serengeti National Park and features. In fact, sources cite that it has happened a total of four times in the past 56 Presidential elections. Loyiso Mqalo. This was the case in both the 2000 and 2016 elections, which were won by George W. Bush and Donald Trump, respectively. Although the Electoral College doesnt recite its final tally until December 19, 2016, the standing vote shows a Trump Victory. Nike's Dream Crazier shines a spotlight on female athletes who have broken barriers, brought people together through their performance and inspired girls around the world. Voters in all 50 states cast ballots for local, state, and congressional offices that directly influence election outcomes. Why did they create the Electoral College? Advocates for alternatives to the Electoral College argue that American political culture has evolved past the filtering effect of electoral votes. Advocates for eliminating electoral votes also point to potential benefits in terms of civic engagement and vote integrity. PDF Why Should We Abolish the Electoral College? - LWV Wilmette Sasik meaning "Loving change and enthusiasm" was born from a tradition spread through three generations of women, of mothers. electoral college Flashcards | Quizlet The Electoral College helps give rural states with lower populations an equal voice. 7 What are the steps in the Electoral College process? For months preceding Election Day, Hilary Clinton led the polls and was the nations favored candidate for President. Abolishing The Electoral College Would Be More Complicated Than - NPR With the electoral system our votes certainly do not count. If the vote was purely a . This was a vote that ultimately become the Senates final decision. Why should political candidates dedicate more of their time campaigning to citizens in some locations versus other areas? Small states are over represented. It is a process that was initially created to establish a fair and just system of voting between the U.S. citizens and members of Congress. Line graph. Time concluded that while rural areas lack the concentration necessary as campaign targets, individual voters from small towns to big cities would have greater influence with a popular vote system than the Electoral College. The organization notes that all of the general election events in the 2012 presidential race took place in 12 states, ignoring 38 states and their voters. National Popular Vote Inc. argues the Electoral College encourages presidential candidates to ignore most states due to the swing-state effect. Please contact your congressional representatives and senators and encourage them to abolish the Electoral College through a constitutional amendment at the earliest opportunity. Although the system has been modified as the years have passed, it is a process that we are comfortable with and, at this point, quite accustomed to. Mood Unchanged, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information, 61% prefer amending Constitution to use popular vote to elect president, 89% of Democrats, 23% of Republicans favor popular vote, Democrats' preference for popular vote highest in two decades. But its time to get serious about a change. This article was published more than2 years ago. As the proud Democratic country, America proud itself to be, we need to come together and tell our congress to pass bills that would abolish this system, which clearly does not favor us and one that that allows a President to be elected even though a majority of the country did not elect him/her. Match Direct Elections at Local and State Level Voters in all 50 states cast ballots for local, state, and congressional offices that directly influence election outcomes. Answer (1 of 8): Because they have NO clue WHY THE EC IS IN THE CONSTITUTION IN THE FIRST PLACE. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); (function(){var i='5CbpgT02ABHdB8Mh-um8FovvMuQm67Ewtc8uEdIuaplW7qYlRBmw';document.write(' This single quote defines the privilege and honor I have had in the last 16 years to witness the evolution of the woman of East Africa Tanzania. 2023, https://www.paperdue.com/essay/three-good-reasons-to-abolish-electoral-college-essay-2175636, Electoral College There is not a single state that relies on the Electoral College to select a Governor, and for good reason. Small states already have disproportionate clout in our government because of the Senate, in which Wyomings fewer than 600,000residents have as much representation as Californias 39.5 million. Far fewer Republicans, 23%, share this view, as 77% of them support keeping the current system in which the candidate with the most votes in the Electoral College wins the election. The Electoral College - Top 3 Pros and Cons - ProCon.org So, why is this an issue? The problem is that we may never know how another system would work in the United States because we are not willing to try it. President Donald Trump won the election in 2016 through the. What needs to happen is the electoral college needs to be gone because it does not produce the peoples choice. It does not always promote fairness. The famed Warren Court, a brief liberal respite in the Supreme Courts longstanding history of reactionary conservatism, established the one person, one vote principle in 1962 with Baker v. Carr and in 1964 with Reynolds v. Sims, stating that the constitution mandated state legislative districts be roughly equal in population, in order to ensure that everyones vote counts the same in statewide elections. This process on the state level would diminish meaningful competition, stack the odds in one partys favor, and create many of the same problems we see on the national level with our current system. Winner-take-all ignores the will of too many voters: The Electoral College should follow the popular vote. Our increasing polarization is reflected in the narrowing number of swing states today. Which States Split Their Electoral Votes? Same for unreasonable search and seizures by the government. Why did they create the Electoral College? - Wise-Answer Are public presidential elections really shams, leaving us with a president who is essentially appointed by political party favorites, or does he represent. The American people have waited long enough! As citizens of the United States, we watched with fervor. This is definitely not something new, it has happened at least four times out of the 56 presidential elections, or more than seven percent of the time. Electoral College When the constitution of United States was framed there were discussions on various methods of selecting the President and the method of a direct popular vote was rejected. The right of suffrage was more diffusive in the Northern than the Southern States; and the latter could have no influence in the election on the score of the Negroes.